Nagar won Rajgarh in 2014, taking the seat from the Congress, and was re-elected in 2019. In 2024 he defeated Congress veteran Digvijaya Singh, polling 7,58,743 votes for a margin of 1,46,089.
In July 2024 Digvijaya Singh filed an election petition in the Madhya Pradesh High Court (Indore bench) seeking to have Nagar's election declared void, raising concerns about EVMs and verification procedures. The court issued notice to Nagar and the Election Commission; no final ruling on the petition has been reported.